Average Retail Price: $480 – 1,899.99+

Tasting Notes Profile

Appearance: The bourbon boasts a burnished copper hue, hinting at its lengthy slumber in oak barrels. The viscous liquid leaves slow-trailing legs as it’s swirled, a testament to its rich body.

Nose: The initial aroma is a pleasant medley, with vanilla bean and caramel leading the charge. Hints of cinnamon and nutmeg weave in, creating a warm, inviting impression. But beneath the surface lies a curious lack of complexity. While whispers of dried fruit and oak are present, they remain shy, failing to create a truly layered experience.

Palate: The first sip offers a velvety texture, coating the tongue with a wave of toasted oak and vanilla. However, the development is somewhat limited. Cherry – a common Buffalo Trace note – takes center stage, though it leans more towards a sweet maraschino character than a deeper, nuanced fruitiness. A subtle layer of vanilla adds a touch of creaminess, but it fails to fully temper the dominance of the cherry or the oak’s dry whispers.

Finish: The finish is brief, echoing the fleeting sweetness of the cherry and a touch of oak. Hints of cinnamon linger on the breath, but the overall experience lacks the lingering complexity one might expect from a 15-year aged bourbon.

Overall Impression

Pappy Van Winkle 15 Year Bourbon is certainly smooth and enjoyable. The initial sip offers a pleasant wave of familiar flavors. However, for a bourbon of such stature, the lack of depth and complexity is a disappointment. The experience feels a bit one-dimensional, with the cherry note dominating the palate throughout.

There’s a certain elegance in its simplicity, some might say. But for the hefty price tag, this reviewer craves a more dynamic performance.

Conclusion: A Rare and Remarkable Dram

Now, let’s be honest – Pappy isn’t for the faint of wallet. Its rarity and reputation drive the price tag to stratospheric heights. But for those who appreciate exceptional whiskey, a pour of Pappy Van Winkle 15 is a must. 

Check it out for yourself here. 

What are your thoughts on Pappy Van Winkle’s 15 Year expression? Share in the comments below